Alfred Hitchcock Presents: The Cheney Vase

Note: This post and the YouTube video embedded in it discuss and depict disability, caretaker abuse, and gaslighting.

I originally had plenty of Things to Say regarding manipulation, emotional abuse, and gaslighting about this episode. But it’s difficult for me to find the right words on this subject, both for intellectual and emotional reasons, so I just kept putting it off and putting it off and putting it off.

At this point — it’s been over two weeks since I first planned to write it — I probably have to either come to terms with the fact that there’s little I can say about it or else declare the whole thing a Post I Meant to Write (but didn’t).


[Alfred Hitchcock Presents "The Cheney Vase." Original air date December 25, 1955. Uploaded via YouTube.]

My thoughts, brief and ineloquent as they are:

  1. Domestic abuse is frighteningly common. You know someone who’s been on the receiving end of domestic abuse. No, really — you do.
  2. Caretaker abuse introduces a complicating element wherein a victim of such abuse may actually not be able to leave. Like, I understand my own personal emotional issues surrounding leaving abusive relationships, and I don’t want to discount any of that. But I can only imagine how having an extra layer of fear — of not being able to meet basic, immediate survival needs — might be.
  3. Gaslighting is just… I don’t even know how to say it. When the last thing you need is anything that makes you doubt your own life and your own truth, it is everything that makes you doubt your own life and your own truth.

Can’t Have Everything

Yellow sticky note with text, "The reason it seems like no one understands what you're going through is because no one understands what you're going through."
I’ve been thinking I’ve been angry at the Internet a lot in the past few days. I mean, there’s the standard “inadvertently glancing at comments on a mainstream media news post” and “dealing with hateful troll comments” types of angry. On their own, I can brush them off pretty easily, but piled on top of others, they’re still part of the baseline. Then there are the hit-or-miss blogs I read occasionally; in the past few days, they’ve been more miss than hit.

But I’ve been most angered by comments in places I’d previously regarded as safe spaces for particular types of conversations and issues.

As it happens, I am wrong — both about those being safe spaces and about me being angry.

Really, I realized during an hour of stepping the fuck away and reminding myself of what yoga feels like, I am hurt.

Previously, I’d considered these spaces to be ones where I could let my guard down regarding things like fat, disability, and body image. For a considerable length of time, especially in Internet terms, that worked well for me. Now, though, it seems that some of those spaces have become more focused on being more educational, discussion-oriented spaces for a wider variety of readers and commenters.

Don’t get me wrong. I’m not saying that these are now bad spaces or that we don’t need spaces that focus on 101-type social justice education. However, I think it’s not always possible to be a space that’s both open to folks who’d like that 101-type explanation to their questions or reservations and that’s supportive of folks who are literally frustrated to screams and tears by the repetitive and potentially insensitive nature of those questions. Can’t always have it both ways.

Which is why I can no longer visit those spaces in the same way — because they are no longer safe spaces for me. In short, when people ask clueless questions or make misinformed comments — even when they do so innocently, respectfully — it hurts unless I put up conscious emotional defenses against it (sometimes even then). Those defenses are stressful, anxiety-inducing. I need places to go where I can be without them sometimes.

Maybe sometimes, I will still visit when I have sufficient psychological reserves. But they can’t be the places I go after a long day at work and in the world, where I’ve been busy being strong for everyone else. They can’t be the notifications the pop up in inboxes and dashboards the ones I might open for sake of the title when I’m really not prepared for what’s inside.

They now join the long list of places I can read when I’m ready to give back even more. The list of spaces I can go to find peace and to restore? That one continues to shorten.

Scared to Ask

This post is part of Blogging Against Disablism Day:

Blogging Against Disablism Day, May 1st 2012

It started when they moved the faculty lounge to the second floor. The faculty lounge is important for two reasons. Not because anyone lounges there but because our mailboxes, which we are required to check daily, live there. Also, they contain the only bathrooms on campus furnished with the luxury of a spare roll of toilet paper in case the first runs out. When there are only five minutes between classes, I don’t exactly have time to drip dry.

Unfortunately, when there are only five minutes between classes, peeing in the faculty bathroom is nothing but a far-off dream. More to the point, though, on a bad pain day, I can’t really get up the stairs in any meaningful time frame. Additionally, with a bleeding disorder, sometimes getting to the bathroom, any bathroom, launches itself from convenience to immediate necessity. In short, moving the faculty lounge upstairs meant I could no longer handle some facets of my job — checking my mailbox daily, inability to go 3.5 hours between bathroom visits — without accommodation.

And I was scared to ask.

First, in terms of claiming I can’t always do stairs, I fit the standard definition of “but you don’t look sick.” That is, I appear mobile on stationary, level surfaces. In fact, sometimes, I even enjoy — and talk about — being pretty active and athletic on those types of surfaces. (Trufax: On bad pain days, hill running is optional. Changing my cup at work, not so much.) Second, part of my need for accommodation has to do with “wimmin’s things” and also blood. There are all kinds of reasons a supervisor at work could react to my concerns as if they’re fabricated, exaggerated, silly, or plain gross. I was worried about those not only as personal reactions from people, but also as reactions that could result in ungood professional consequences for me.

I’m good at my job. How fast I can climb stairs or how often I end up filling my menstrual cup is unrelated to what makes me a good teacher.

Fortunately, when I asked, the people who responded were understanding, professional, and responsive. I received both key access to the building’s elevator as well as an arranged system with my neighboring teacher, who also happened to be my department chair for how to handle emergency gushing sessions. Dealing with my endo continued to be supremely unfun, but at least I wasn’t worried about work logistics complicating the issue.

But. Time passed. Employee assignments shuffled. I’m in a different department. Both the department chair and the assistant principal I’d originally come to with my concerns have moved on to positions at different schools. (Relatively up the employment ladder for both of them, perhaps as a result of them also being damn good at their own jobs.) The people who had been looking out for me — in fact, the only people who had known about my endo — are gone.

And now I’m moving too. Same school, but a different program and different building. I don’t know where my room will be next year, or what it will mean in relation to my mobility and blood-gushing needs. Part of me thinks I should speak up. My current supervisor is, by my own experience, as fair and understanding as the one who came before. If everyone is open and reasonable, odds are pretty strong that we could come up with a new set of workable accommodations.

Once again, though, I am scared to ask. For all of the same reasons — fear I will be ignored, fear I will be belittled. And most of all, fear that people will think I am somehow incompetent or unable — and a lot of times, people conflate the two — at my job. Regardless of what should happen, what does happen is that I worry that people will confuse “I need help with the logistics” — which are, after all, really arbitrary here — with me being a fundamentally inadequate teacher.

It is, perhaps, ableism at its most efficient. I’ve internalized the anticipated negative responses so well that no one even has to tell me “no.” I’m scared to ask… and so I don’t.